All Star Superman Review: Grant Morrison’s DC Masterpiece
INTRODUCTION: Revisiting a Legend
Welcome to our All Star Superman Review. Writing this piece allowed me to revisit one of my favorite comics. Interestingly, I am not usually a massive fan of the Man of Steel. I typically prefer him as a side character in a Batman story. However, this book changed everything for me.
Grant Morrison wrote this story as a perfect jumping-in point. Consequently, new readers can enjoy the plot with zero prior knowledge. Even if you know the lore, you will love Morrison’s fresh take on the character.
STORY: A Brisk and Cosmic Journey
In this All Star Superman Review, we look at how the plot moves at a brisk pace. Morrison avoids making the story convoluted. They keep readers informed without ever talking down to them. This balance makes the book feel accessible yet sophisticated.
I love the opening. Morrison shows Superman’s origin on a single page. Then, a beautiful two-page spread displays the Man of Steel in his full glory. The book embraces cosmic themes early on. We see Superman flying around the sun in a display of pure power. Furthermore, the relationship between Kal El and Lois Lane evolves beautifully. This layer adds deep complexity to the alien hero.
THE VILLAINS: Lex Luthor at His Best
The other major relationship in the book is with Lex Luthor. Morrison writes Lex as an unflinching sociopath. This version of the character is willing to do anything to achieve his goals.
Luthor provides a perfect contrast to Superman’s optimism. His presence raises the stakes of the story. Ultimately, it makes the resolution of the plot feel earned and impactful.
ARTWORK: Frank Quitely’s Iconic Style
Frank Quitely’s art smoothly compliments the narrative. His clean and crisp illustrations make the book iconic. I personally enjoy the “Desperate Dan” build of Superman. It acts as a great homage to the comics of Quitely’s youth.
Jamie Grant’s colors also help make the book recognizable. Each page features bright and varied tones. However, the colors never look garish. Instead, they bring every panel to life.
VERDICT: The Final All Star Superman Review
I enjoyed re-reading this book just as much as the first time. Morrison hit the nail on the head. They gave us the quintessential alternative version of the Man of Steel. It is certainly better than its All Star Batman and Robin counterpart.
Story: 10/10
Art: 10/10
Overall Rating: 5/5 Stars
Check out our other legendary reviews:
Want to read the masterpiece? Buy All Star Superman on Amazon.
